Amish Peanut Butter Cream Pie

WANT TO SAVE THIS RECIPE?

I still remember the first time I tasted Amish Peanut Butter Cream Pie—its silky filling, nutty depth, and cloud of whipped cream made an instant impression. The combination of creamy peanut butter and buttery graham cracker crust hits just the right balance of rich and light, making it a dessert I reach for when I want to wow my guests with something both comforting and unexpected.

Over time, I’ve fine-tuned this pie to suit my own tastes, leaning into that signature peanut flavor while keeping the filling soft and airy. It’s a no-bake wonder, perfect for warm weather when you’d rather not turn on the oven, but honestly, I’ll make it year-round. I’m excited to share my take on this delightful dessert with you.

---

Why You’ll Love This Amish Peanut Butter Cream Pie

This pie offers everything a peanut butter lover dreams of. The texture is luxuriously smooth, like a mousse, with the perfect contrast of a crisp, buttery crust and a light whipped topping. It’s quick to put together, doesn’t require baking, and can be made ahead—perfect for holidays, potlucks, or an anytime treat. The familiar flavor of peanut butter shines, elevated by a touch of sweetness and a whisper of salt. Once you try it, you’ll be hooked.

---

What Kind of Peanut Butter Should I Use?

For Amish Peanut Butter Cream Pie, I always recommend using a smooth, creamy peanut butter like Jif or Skippy. These commercial brands give the filling a consistent texture and balanced flavor. Natural peanut butters, while delicious on their own, tend to separate and can cause the pie filling to become oily or grainy. If you love the rustic texture of natural peanut butter, try stirring it very thoroughly and be aware that the final texture may differ slightly.

---

Options for Substitutions

While I’m pretty loyal to the classic version, this pie can absolutely be customized to suit your tastes or dietary needs:

• Crust: If you’re not a graham cracker fan, try using an Oreo crust or even a pretzel crust for a salty twist.
• Peanut Butter: Almond butter or cashew butter can replace peanut butter for a different flavor profile.
• Whipped Topping: You can substitute homemade whipped cream for store-bought whipped topping if you prefer a richer taste.
• Milk: Whole milk yields the creamiest filling, but 2% milk works well too. For a dairy-free version, almond milk or oat milk can be used, though the texture may be a bit lighter.
• Sweeteners: Swap out white sugar for powdered sugar if you want a silkier, less granular sweetness in the filling.

Experimenting with these options lets you create a pie that’s just right for you and your guests.

---

Ingredients for Amish Peanut Butter Cream Pie

Each ingredient in this pie plays a key role in achieving that creamy, indulgent result:

• Graham Cracker Crumbs
  The base of the crust—adds a buttery crunch and a light sweetness that pairs beautifully with the filling.
• Butter
  Used to bind the graham cracker crumbs into a sturdy crust. Salted butter adds a little extra flavor contrast.
• Granulated Sugar
  Sweetens both the crust and the filling just enough to balance the rich peanut butter.
• Creamy Peanut Butter
  The star ingredient! It provides the luscious, nutty body of the pie.
• Cream Cheese
  Adds structure and a subtle tang, keeping the filling smooth and stable.
• Powdered Sugar
  Helps sweeten and lighten the peanut butter-cream cheese mixture without adding grittiness.
• Whipped Topping
  Folds into the filling for an airy texture and tops the pie with a cloud of sweetness.
• Milk
  Loosens the filling to the perfect creamy consistency.
• Peanut Butter Chips or Crushed Peanuts (optional)
  Sprinkled on top for added texture and a little visual flair.

Each element comes together to create a pie that’s rich but not heavy, creamy with just the right amount of crunch.

---

Step 1: Prepare the Crust

Start by combining graham cracker crumbs, melted butter, and granulated sugar in a mixing bowl. Stir until the crumbs are evenly coated and resemble wet sand. Press the mixture firmly into the bottom and up the sides of a pie plate. Chill the crust in the refrigerator for at least 30 minutes to set.

---

Step 2: Make the Peanut Butter Filling

In a large bowl, beat the cream cheese until smooth and creamy. Add the powdered sugar and beat again until well combined. Mix in the peanut butter and a splash of milk, blending until the mixture is silky and uniform.

---

Step 3: Fold in Whipped Topping

Gently fold half of the whipped topping into the peanut butter mixture using a spatula. This lightens the filling and gives it a mousse-like texture. Be careful not to overmix—you want to keep it airy.

---

Step 4: Fill the Crust

Spoon the peanut butter filling into the prepared graham cracker crust, spreading it evenly with a spatula. Smooth the top as best you can, though a few swirls add a nice homemade touch.

---

Step 5: Top and Garnish

Spread the remaining whipped topping over the peanut butter layer. If you like, sprinkle peanut butter chips or crushed peanuts on top for extra texture and a hint of crunch.

---

Step 6: Chill

Refrigerate the pie for at least 4 hours, or overnight if possible. This allows the filling to set properly and makes the pie easier to slice.

---

How Long to Cook the Amish Peanut Butter Cream Pie

One of my favorite things about this pie is that it’s completely no-bake—no cooking required! The only “cooking” involved is chilling time. You’ll want to refrigerate the assembled pie for at least 4 hours, though I often leave it overnight to ensure it’s perfectly set. The chilling allows the filling to firm up and the flavors to meld beautifully.

---

Tips for Perfect Amish Peanut Butter Cream Pie

• Use room temperature cream cheese
  This helps it blend smoothly with the other ingredients and prevents lumps.
• Don’t skip chilling the crust
  A well-chilled crust holds together better when slicing.
• Fold, don’t stir, the whipped topping
  Gentle folding keeps the filling light and fluffy.
• Plan ahead
  This pie tastes even better the next day, making it ideal for preparing in advance.
• Use creamy peanut butter
  For the best texture and flavor, stick with a smooth, well-mixed peanut butter.
• Add garnish just before serving
  If using peanut butter chips or crushed peanuts, sprinkle them on just before serving to keep them crisp.

---

Watch Out for These Mistakes While Cooking

Even though Amish Peanut Butter Cream Pie is simple to make, a few common missteps can affect the outcome:

• Using natural peanut butter without stabilizing it
  Natural peanut butter can cause the filling to become oily or gritty unless it’s well-stirred and stabilized. Stick with classic creamy peanut butter for best results.
• Not softening the cream cheese
  Cold cream cheese won’t blend smoothly, resulting in lumps. Let it come to room temperature first.
• Overmixing the whipped topping
  Folding too vigorously can deflate the whipped topping, making the filling dense instead of airy.
• Skipping the chill time
  The pie needs time to set. Cutting it too soon will result in a runny filling.
• Overloading with garnishes
  Too many toppings can weigh down the light filling. A simple sprinkle is enough.

---

What to Serve With Amish Peanut Butter Cream Pie?

Pairing this pie with other flavors can make your dessert table sing. Here are a few ideas:

Fresh Berries

Raspberries, strawberries, or blueberries offer a bright contrast to the rich peanut butter filling.

Chocolate Sauce

Drizzle a little warm chocolate sauce over each slice for a decadent touch.

Coffee or Espresso

A strong cup of coffee or espresso balances the sweetness of the pie beautifully.

Vanilla Ice Cream

Serve a small scoop on the side for an extra indulgent treat.

Whipped Cream with Cocoa Powder

A dusting of cocoa powder over freshly whipped cream adds elegance.

Salted Caramel Sauce

A drizzle of salted caramel plays up the sweet-and-salty profile.

Roasted Nuts

Offer a small dish of roasted, salted peanuts or mixed nuts alongside the pie.

---

Storage Instructions

Amish Peanut Butter Cream Pie stores wonderfully, making it a great make-ahead dessert. Here’s how to keep it at its best:

• Refrigerator
  Cover the pie loosely with plastic wrap or foil and store it in the refrigerator. It will stay fresh for up to 4–5 days. The flavors tend to deepen after a day, so it’s a perfect dessert to prepare ahead of time.
• Freezer
  You can also freeze the pie! Wrap it tightly in plastic wrap and then in aluminum foil to prevent freezer burn. It will keep for up to 1 month. Thaw it in the refrigerator overnight before serving. Keep in mind that freezing may slightly alter the texture of the whipped topping.
• Serving After Storage
  If the pie has been in the fridge for a while, let it sit at room temperature for about 10 minutes before slicing for cleaner cuts.

---

Estimated Nutrition

Here’s a rough estimate per slice (assuming the pie is cut into 8 slices):

• Calories: ~450
• Fat: ~28g
• Saturated Fat: ~12g
• Carbohydrates: ~35g
• Sugar: ~20g
• Protein: ~8g
• Fiber: ~2g
• Sodium: ~300mg

Please note, these numbers can vary depending on the exact brands and quantities used. If you’re following a specific dietary plan, it’s always a good idea to calculate based on your actual ingredients.

---

With the right storage and an understanding of its nutritional profile, you can enjoy Amish Peanut Butter Cream Pie any time!

Frequently Asked Questions

What size pie dish should I use?

A standard 9-inch pie dish works perfectly for this recipe. You can use a glass, ceramic, or metal pie plate—just make sure it’s deep enough to hold all that luscious filling.

---

Can I make this pie ahead of time?

Absolutely! In fact, the pie is best when it’s had time to chill for several hours or overnight. This makes it a fantastic make-ahead dessert for gatherings or holidays.

---

Is this pie freezer-friendly?

Yes. You can freeze the pie for up to a month. Be sure to wrap it well in plastic wrap and foil. Thaw overnight in the refrigerator before serving. Keep in mind that the whipped topping may soften slightly after freezing.

---

Can I use crunchy peanut butter?

Technically, yes, but keep in mind it will change the texture of the filling. For the smoothest, most traditional Amish Peanut Butter Cream Pie, I recommend creamy peanut butter.

---

Can I use homemade whipped cream instead of store-bought?

Definitely! If you prefer homemade whipped cream, just whip about 2 cups of heavy cream with powdered sugar to taste and use it in place of the whipped topping.

---

How do I prevent a soggy crust?

Make sure to chill the crust thoroughly before adding the filling. This helps it firm up so it holds its shape once the filling is added.

---

Is this recipe gluten-free?

The filling itself is gluten-free, but graham crackers typically contain gluten. You can easily make it gluten-free by using gluten-free graham crackers for the crust.

---

How long will leftovers keep?

Leftovers will keep 4–5 days in the refrigerator. Cover the pie loosely to prevent it from drying out or absorbing other odors.

---

Conclusion

Amish Peanut Butter Cream Pie is one of those magical desserts that looks impressive, tastes heavenly, and comes together with minimal effort. The creamy peanut butter filling and buttery graham cracker crust create a perfect harmony of textures and flavors. Whether you serve it for a holiday, a potluck, or a simple family dinner, it’s guaranteed to become a crowd favorite. I hope you enjoy making and sharing this delightful pie as much as I do!

---

Print